EDUCATIONAL FINANCE IN WESTERN EUROPE: SOME EXPERIENCES FROM A TANGLED WEB

Jan Werner

Authors

Jan Werner Institute of Local Finances, Lengen

Keywords:

Intergovernmental transfers, educational finance, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, United Kingdom.

Abstract

Education is one of the most important services provided by public governments in almost every country worldwide. However, the most important cross-country observations about education – like the PISA report by the OECD or the TIMSS by the IEA – focus only on international benchmarks to compare the knowledge capacity of pupils. This paper provides a general overview of the different forms how education expenditures are financed in ten European countries. We observe the educational system in Austria, Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and the United Kingdom and point out the similarities and national distinctions.

References

Albouy, Valerie / Waneck, Thomas (2003) : Les ine´galite´s sociales d’acce`s aux Grandes Ecoles in Economie et Statistique, Number 361, page 27–47.

Brosio, Giorgio (2004): Intergovernmental relations in Italy, Survey report No. 5 on European Fiscality by the l'Institut de Recherches Economiques et Fiscales, Paris / France: l'Institut de Recherches Economiques et Fiscales

Cameron, Stephen. V., / Heckman, James. J. (2001): The dynamics of educational attainment for Black, Hispanic, and White males in Journal of Political Economy, Volume 109, Issue 3, page 455–499.

Caille, Jean P. (2001) : Les collégiens de ZEP à la fin des années 90: caractéristiques des élèves et impact de la scolarisation en ZEP sur la réussite in Education et Formations, Volume 61, Issue 1, page 111–140.

Clark, Demon (2005) : Politics, Markets and Schools: Quasi-Experimental Evidence on the Impact of Autonomy and Competition from a Truly Revolutionary UK Reform, Mimeo.

Currie, Janet (2001): Early Childhood Education Programs in Journal of Economic Perspectives, Volume 15, Issue 2, page 213–238.

Cunha, Flavio / Heckman, James J. / Lochner, Lance and Masterov, Dmitry V. (2005): Interpreting the Evidence on Life Cycle Skill Formation, NBER Working Paper 11331, Cambridge / USA.

Dafflon, Bernard (2004): Federal-Cantonal Equalisation in Switzerland: An Overview of the Present System and Reform in Progress, Working Paper No 356 of BENEFRI Centre d'Études en Économie du Secteur Public (CÉÉP), Faculté des Sciences Economiques et Sociales, University of Freiburg / Switzerland.

Davoodi, Hamid / Zou, Heng fu (1998): Fiscal Decentralization and Economic Growth: A Cross-Country Study in Journal of Urban Economics, Volume 43, Issue 2, page 244--257.

Duss, Roland / Bird, Richard M. (1979): Switzerland’s Tax Jungle in Canadian Tax Journal, Volume 27, Issue 1, page 46-67.

Entorf, Horst / Minoiu, Nicoleta (2005): What a Difference Immigration Policy Makes: A Comparison of PISA Scores in Europe and Traditional Countries of Immigration in German Economic Review Volume 6, Issue 3, page 355–376.

Entwisle, Doris R. / Alexander, Karl L. and Olson, Steffel L. (1997): Children, Schools, and Inequality, 1.Edition, Colorado / USA: B. Westview Press.

Feld, Lars P. / Kirchgässner; Gebhardt and Schaltegger, Christoph A. (2003): Decentralized Taxation and the Size of Government: Evidence from Swiss State and Local Government, CESifo Working Paper No. 1087.

Fisman, Raymond / Gatti, Roberta (2002): Decentralization and Corruption: Evidence Across Countries in Journal of Public Economics, Volume 83, Issue 3, page 325–345.

Frey, Bruno / Eichenberger; Reiner (1995): Competition among Jurisdictions: The Idea of FOCJ in Lüder, Gerken (ed.), Competition among Jurisdictions, 1.Edition, London / United Kingdom: Macmillan.

Fuchs, Thomas / Wößmann, Ludger (2004): Computers and Student Learning: Bivariate and Multivariate Evidence on the Availability and Use of Computers at Home and at School in Brussels Economic Review, Volume 47, Issue 3-4, page 359–385.

Fuchs, Thomas / Wößmann, Ludger (2007): What Accounts for International Differences in Student Performance? A Re-examination Using PISA Data in Empirical Economics, Volume 32, Issue 2–3, page 433–464 .

Fukasaku, Kiichiro / de Mello, Luiz (1998): Fiscal Decentralization and Macroeconomic Stability: The Experience of Large Developing Countries and Transition Economies in Fukasaku, Kiichiro and Hausmann, Ricardo (ed.), Decentralisation and Deficits in Latin America, 1.Edition, Paris / France: OECD

Gérard, Marcel (2001): Fiscal Federalism in Belgium, Paper for the conference on Fiscal Imbalance in Quebec City / Canada at September 13–14, 2001.

Gershberg, Alec I. / Winkler, Donald R. (2003): Education Decentralisation in Africa: A Review of Recent Policy Practise, mimeo

Glennerster, Howard (1991): Quasi-markets for education? in Economic Journal, Volume 101, Issue 408, page 1268–1276.

Guengant, Alain / Josselin, Jean-Michael (2006): Local Power to Tax and Devolution: An Empirical Assessment of the French Constitutional Reform, Working paper 12-2006 of the Centre for Research in Economics and Management at the Universities of Rennes 1 and Caen

Guihéry, Laurent / Werner, Jan (2005): Les finances publiques en Allemagne – Quelles réformes? in Revue de l'OFCE , Volume 94, page 111–137.

Gundlach, Erich / Gmelin, Jens and Wößmann, Ludger (2001): The Decline of Schooling Productivity in OECD Countries in Economic Journal, Volume 111, Issue 471, page 135–147.

Hanushek, Erich A. (2003): The Failure of Input-Based Schooling Policies in Economic Journal, Volume 113, Issue 485, page F64–F98.

Hedges, Larry / Laine, Richard D. and Greenwald, Robert (1994): Does money matter? A meta-nalysis of studies of the effects of differential school inputs on

Hoxby, Caroline M. (1996): How Teachers’ Unions Affect Education Production in Quarterly Journal of Economics, Volume 111, Issue 3, page 671–718

Hoxby, Caroline M. (2003): School Choice and School Competition: Evidence from the United States in Swedish Economic Policy Review Volume10, Issue 3, page 9–65.

Huther, Jeff / Shah, Anwar (1998): Applying a Simple Measure of Good Governance to the Debate on Fiscal Decentralization, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 1894.

Krueger, Alan B. (2003): Economic Considerations and Class Size in Economic Journal, Volume 113, Issue 485, page 34–63.

McNeal,, Ralph (1995): Extracurricular activities and high school dropouts in Sociology of Education, Volume 68, Issue 1, page 62–80.

Meuret, Denis (1994): L’efficacité de la politique des zones d’éducation prioritaires dans les collèges in Revue française de Pédagogie, n° 109, page pp. 41–64.

Meuret, Denis (2001) : Les Recherches sur la réduction de la Taille des Classes, Rapport pour le Haut Conseil de l’Evaluation de l’Ecole, Paris /France.

Neal, Derek A. (2002): How Vouchers Could Change the Market for Education in Journal of Economic Perspectives Volume 26, Issue, page 25–44.

OECD (2008): Education at a Glance 2008, 1. Edition, Paris / France: OECD.

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (ODPM) (2005): Local Government Financial Statistics England No.16, 1.Edition, London / United Kingdom: Office of the Deputy Prime Minister.

Planungsausschuß für den Hochschulbau (UBPC) (2005): 34. Rahmenplan für den Hochschulbau nach dem Hochschulbauförderungsgesetz 2005–2008, 1. Edition, Berlin / Germany: Planungs-ausschuß für den Hochschulbau.

Plug, Erik (2004): Estimating the Effect of Mother’s Schooling on Children’s Schooling Using a Sample of Adoptees in American Economic Review Volume 94, Issue 1, page 358–368.

Pritchett, Lant / Filmer, Deon (1999): What Education Production Functions Really Show: A Positive Theory of Education Expenditure, Economics of Education Review, Volume 18, Issue 2, page 223–239.

Prud´homme, Remy (1995): Dangers of Decentralization in Word Bank Research Observer, Volume 10, Issue 2, page 201–210.

Prud’homme, Rémy (2006): Local Government Organization and Finance in France in Shah, Anwar (ed.), Local Governance in Industrial Countries, 1.Edition, Washington, DC / USA: World Bank.

Schaltegger, Christoph A. / Frey, René (2003): Finanzausgleich und Föderalismus: Zur Neugestaltung der föderalen Finanzbeziehungen am Beispiel der Schweiz in Perspektiven der Wirtschaftspolitik, Volume 4, Issue 2, page 239–258.

Schütz, Gabrielle / Ursprung, Heinrich W. and Wößmann, Ludger (2008): Education Policy and Equality of Opportunity in Kyklos, Volume 61, Issue 5, page 279–308.

Schütz, Gabrielle / Wößmann, Ludger (2005): Chancengleichheit im Schulsystem: Internationale deskriptive Evidenz und mögliche Bestimmungsfaktoren, Ifo Working paper 17, München / Germany.

Shah, Anwar (1995): Theory and Practise of Intergovernmental Transfers in Ahmad, Ehtisham / Qiang, Gao / Tanzi, Vito (ed.), Reforming China’s Public Finance, 1. Edition, Washington, DC / USA: International Monetary Fund.

Spahn, Paul Bernd, / Franz, Oliver (2002): Consensus Democracy and Interjurisdictional Fiscal Solidarity in Germany in Ahmad Ehtisham and Vito Tanzi (eds.), Managing Fiscal Decentralization, Routledge Studies in the Modern World Economy, London / United Kingdom, Routledge Taylor & Francis Group.

Spahn, Paul Bernd / Werner, Jan (2007): Germany at the Junction between Solidarity and Subsidiarity in Richard Bird und Robert Ebel (ed.), Fiscal Fragmentation in Decentralized Countries: Subsidiarity, Solidarity and Asymmetry, Cheltenham / United Kingdom: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Spahn, Paul Bernd (2007): Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations, and Structural Problems of Federalism in Belgium, Report prepared for the International Monetary Fund, Washington D. C. / USA

Sutton, Alice / Soderstrom, Irine (1999): Predicting elementary and secondary school achievement with school-related and demographic factors in Journal of Educational Research, Volume 92, Issue 6, page 330–338.

Tanzi, Vito (2000): Some Politically Incorrect Remarks on Decentralisation and Public Finance in Dethier, Jean-Jaques (ed.), Governance, Decentralisation and Reform in China, India and Russia, 1.Edition, Dordrecht / Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publisher.

Treisman, Daniel (2000): The Causes of Corruption: A Cross-National Study in Journal of Public Economics, Volume 76, Issue 3, page 399-457.

Torgler, Benno / Werner, Jan (2005): Tax Morale and Fiscal Autonomy: Evidence from Germany in Public Finance and Management, Volume 5, Issue 4, page 423–452.

Van der Stichele, Géraldine / Verdonck, Magali (2001): Les modifications de la loi spéciale de financement dans l'accord du Lambermont in Courrier Hebdomadaire, Volume 43, Issue 1733, page 1–52.

Werner, Jan / Guihéry, Laurent and Djukic, Ognjen (2006): Fiscal Federalism in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Ten Years after the Dayton Treatment and Still not in a Steady Condition, in Journal of Economic Asymmetries, Volume 3, Issue 2, page 125–148.

Werner, Jan / Shah, Anwar (2005): Equalisation and Local Taxation in Denmark, Norway and Sweden, ILPF Working paper 02-2005, page 1–21.

Werner, Jan (2003): El federalismo Alemán: en Estado de Fluctuación in Zergak Gaceta Tributaria del Pais Vasco, Volume 25, Issue 3, page 81–114.

Werner, Jan (2007): Fiskaldezentralisierung, Report prepared for the GTZ, Eschborn / Germany, page 1–19.

Werner, Jan (2008a): Das deutsche Gemeindefinanzsystem: Reformvorschläge im Kontext der unterschiedlichen Einnahmenautonomie der lokalen Gebietskörperschaften in Europa, 1.Edition, Frankfurt am Main / Germany: Peter Lang.

Werner, Jan (2008b): Fiscal Equalisation and Fiscal Conflicts are Like the Chicken or Egg Question – Which Came First? in Ron Watts and Rupak Chattopadhyay (eds.) Unity in Diversity: Learning From Each Other: Fiscal Federalism – Volume 2, New Delhi / India, Viva Books.

Werner, Jan (2008c): El Modelo de Financiación de los Länder de Alemania: Características Generales y Nivelación Fiscal in Parlamento Vasco (ed.) Federalismo Fiscal y Europa, Vitoria-Gasteiz / Spain, Gráficas Santamaría.

Winkler, Donald R. (1989): Decentralisation in Education: An Economic Perspective, Working Paper No. 143 of Population and Human Resources Department of the World Bank, 1.Edition, Washington, DC / USA: World Bank.

Winkler, Donald R. (1989): The Design and Administration of Intergovernmental Transfers: Fiscal Decentralization in Latin America, World Bank Discussion Paper No. 235, 1.Edition, Washington, DC / USA: World Bank.

Wößmann, Ludger / West, Martin R. (2006): Class-Size Effects in School Systems Around the World: Evidence from Between-Grade Variation in TIMSS in European Economic Review, Volume 50, Issue 3, page 695–736.

Wößmann, Ludger (2003): Schooling Resources, Educational Institutions and Student Performance: the International Evidence in Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics Volume 65, Issue 2, page 117–170.